Have I got a Defined Benefit Pension?

We have been finding many people lately with DB pensions from the UK and feel that everyone who has one or think they may have one knows about their options.

To give you an idea of how things may have increased, the last two clients with final salary schemes that we retrieved valuations for had increased 30% since 2015, therefore I am hoping you will be pleasantly surprised and fully informed.

We are also finding that 90% of ALL DB Schemes in the UK are severely underfunded with HMRC reviewing this constantly as this will have a huge effect on the UK financially and potentially less of a payout at retirement for your pension. There are some article links at the end of this if you wish to know more.


Have I got a defined benefit pension?

A defined benefit pension (DB) is a type of workplace pension which:

  • Gives you an income that is normally based on your salary, length of service with your employer (or service in the scheme) and a calculation made under the rules of the pension scheme.
  • You should receive statements which set out how much pension per year you are expected to receive when you reach your normal retirement age.
  • If you work in the public sector or have been a member of a workplace pension scheme for some years, you may have a DB pension entitlement.

If you took out a personal pension this will not be a defined benefit pension.

What other pension types might I have?

Most pension schemes that people join now are “defined contribution”.

  • This is a personal or workplace pension based on how much money has been paid into your pot.
  • When you take money from a defined contribution pension scheme it comes from the money you (and sometimes your employer) saved into it over the years, plus any investment returns your money may have earned.
  • There is no guaranteed amount of pension –and you could get back less than the amount you paid in.

Why are defined benefit pensions valuable?

With defined contribution pensions, you can decide how you take your money out – with defined benefit pensions, your employer guarantees a certain amount of pension each year when you retire.

Because of the guaranteed nature of defined benefit pensions they are often seen as more valuable than defined contribution pensions, as the risks (for instance of living longer than expected or of investments under-performing) are under-written by the employer rather than the individual themselves. The Pensions Regulator also believes that is likely to be in the best financial interests of the majority of members to remain in their DB scheme.

Can I take any cash from my defined benefit pension?  NO !

Until the age of 60 or 65 you will not receive anything from a DB Scheme.

BUT – By transferring to a SIPP or QROPS you can have more flexibility:

  • You can normally take a 25% pension commencement lump sum when you retire from a DB Pension (typically up to 25% of the value of your pension) but you will generally have to give up a part of your pension for cash.
  • The rate for giving up pension for cash will be set by the scheme trustees. These are not guaranteed and may change from time to time in line with changing financial conditions.
  • The amount of lump sum you wish to take will depend on your preference and needs, either you take the pension commencement lump sum or a higher income for the rest of your life.

How do the new pension flexibilities affect me?

The changes outlined by the Chancellor of the Exchequer in the March 2014 Budget brought about some significant changes to the way in which defined contribution pensions can be accessed, with effect from 6 April 2015. The flexibilities do not apply to defined benefit pensions. The Pension Wise service is available to anyone over 55 who has a defined contribution pension arrangement

Therefore, if you only have a defined benefit pension arrangement you will not be eligible for the service.

Can people with defined benefit pensions access the new flexibilities?

The only way that a person can take advantage of the flexibilities is to transfer out of their DB pension scheme into a new or existing defined contribution arrangement, which will offer you flexibility. However, if you are in a public sector scheme you will not be able to transfer your benefits out if the scheme is an unfunded one. If you do transfer and you are at an age where you can take your benefits, you will be able to access the funds in the way you wish, but check that the rules of the receiving arrangement allow you to do this.

However, in order to transfer out you (and your employer) must have stopped contributing to the scheme. You should consider carefully as to whether it is in your interests to opt out of membership of the DB scheme as DB schemes have considerable security and you may be losing out on valuable benefits. You will also generally be required to take independent financial advice before being allowed to transfer. If you are currently in receipt of a pension, you will be unable to transfer out of a DB scheme.

Do I have to transfer out all of my benefits in a scheme?

You will generally need to transfer out all of your DB benefits in a scheme (referred to as “Guaranteed benefit”). However, some schemes may allow you to transfer only a portion of your benefits out of the scheme, but you should check with the scheme administrators about what is permissible. If you also hold defined contribution benefits in the same scheme, you will be able to leave these benefits in the scheme while transferring out your DB benefits.

A member’s transfer right applies to each type of benefit you hold in a scheme, rather than to all the benefits in a scheme. You will have different options to access pension flexibilities depending on the type of benefits in the scheme, for instance if you have defined contribution benefits such as Additional Voluntary Contributions (AVCs).

How do I transfer out if I wish to?

  • Members who are more than one year away from their scheme’s normal retirement age have the right to transfer their DB benefits out of the scheme (unless they are in a public sector scheme which does not permit transfer).
  • Every 12 months you have a right to request a transfer value quotation from the scheme. Your scheme may allow you more frequent requests, although you may be charged for this.
  • When you request a transfer, the trustees of the scheme need to provide you with a “statement of entitlement”. The trustees normally have 3 months from the date of your request to provide you with this statement, although in certain circumstances, this can be extended to 6 months.
  • The statement will provide you with a “Cash Equivalent Transfer Value” (CETV): the CETV is the current value of your benefits within the scheme.
  • The transfer value is normally guaranteed for 3 months from the calculation date (known as the guarantee date) and the trustees should generally pay the transfer value to the accepting pension arrangement within 6 months of the guarantee date.
  • You should be aware that, from April 2015, there will be requirements on trustees when members request a transfer out of a DB scheme where the transfer value is over £30,000. To protect people from making poor choices, there will be a mandatory advice requirement for any member who wants to transfer out to take independent, financial advice from a suitably qualified person. Trustees will need to check that this has been taken before allowing any transfer to go ahead.
  • Members will be expected to meet the cost of this advice, although trustees will not be responsible for checking what advice was given. If you need help in finding a financial adviser, the Money Advice Service has a directory of authorised advisers on its website (directory.moneyadviceservice.org.uk)
  • Schemes are required to notify members about what they have to do and the information the scheme will need to complete a transfer. If a member doesn’t provide what the scheme needs the trustees aren’t obliged to complete the transfer.

How does my scheme calculate the value of my benefits?

  • The cash equivalent transfer value of your benefits is calculated by the scheme actuary. It represents what the actuary and the trustees consider a fair value of the benefits you have given up in the scheme.
  • The calculation will take into account many factors, including how long you might be expected to live and future inflation and investment returns. The trustees will review the assumptions underlying these calculations on a regular basis.
  • It is important to note, that the cash equivalent transfer value you receive may not allow you to purchase from an insurance company, the same level of benefits you have given up. This is because insurers and other providers of retirement products will take a more cautious view of the future, so the cost of buying an income with these companies will tend to be higher.
  • You should also be aware that if the scheme is currently underfunded, the trustees may decide to pay transfer values at a reduced level until full funding is restored. The trustees need to tell you if they are applying any reduction to your transfer value because of underfunding.

What is the role of the trustees of a defined benefit pension schemes?

DB pension schemes are looked after by a board of trustees.

These trustees have a duty in law to act in the interests of all members.

  • When approaching requests out of the scheme, they must balance the interests of both the members wishing to exercise their right to transfer with those that wish to remain in the scheme. This is why they may, from time to time, reduce the amounts paid out if there are insufficient funds in the scheme at a particular point in time.
  • Most importantly, there is a legal requirement on the trustees, set by the Pensions Regulator, to check that a member has obtained appropriate independent financial advice before a transfer is allowed to proceed. This is because, for many people, transferring out of a DB scheme will not be in their best financial interests.
  • You will need to provide the trustees with confirmation that you have obtained such advice, which sets out the relevant details of your adviser, who needs to be authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).
  • The trustees do not need to review this advice, but they do need to be satisfied that you have been properly advised. If you have a small amount of benefits in a DB pension scheme (valued by the trustees as £30,000 or less) then the trustees do not need to check whether you have received this advice. However, you still need to be sure that giving up this guaranteed level of income is in your best interests.

What will an independent financial adviser do?

The adviser will consider all your personal and financial circumstances when considering whether a transfer out of a DB scheme is in your best interests. For some individuals there may be advantages of moving out of a DB scheme into one in which you can access the new pension flexibilities. A regulated financial adviser will provide more information on the pros and cons of such a transfer.

Can the trustees stop me transferring out?

Apart from ensuring that you have received proper advice, the trustees are expected to conduct proper due diligence on the scheme which you intend to transfer your benefits to. In some cases the trustees may have reason to believe that the receiving scheme is not a legitimate one and in these cases they will need to carefully consider whether to allow the transfer to proceed. This may happen if the proposed new scheme presents the warning signs of a pension scam.

If they do this, they may be stopping you transferring to a plan where you might lose a significant proportion, or in some cases, all of your pension savings and be faced with a large tax bill. If the trustees are conducting further investigations they should contact you to explain why there is a delay and why, in some cases, they are not permitting the transfer to proceed. Where a request is made to transfer benefits overseas, the trustees will also need to check whether the receiving scheme is one qualified to receive UK pension benefits.

What if am offered an “enhanced” transfer value?

In some cases, companies running DB pension schemes may wish to reduce their exposure to DB pensions, by offering members beneficial terms to transfer out from the scheme. They will calculate the transfer value on the usual basis but will then apply an enhancement to this. Typically, they will write to members explaining their options and advising them how long this offer lasts for. You will still need to take independent financial advice if you wish to take advantage of this offer and transfer out, but in most cases the employer will offer to pay for this financial advice.

Additional Voluntary Contributions (AVCs)

A member of a DB scheme may have decided to make contributions in excess to those required by the scheme in order to enhance your pension income. These are known as Additional Voluntary Contributions (AVCs) and are often defined contribution in nature. If you have made defined contribution AVCs to a DB scheme in the past, then you may be able to take advantage of the new flexibilities. You should check if your scheme allows you to take advantage of these flexibilities. If not, they may allow you to transfer some or all of your AVCs out to another arrangement which does allow the flexibilities.

Useful articles;

  1. The current pension valuations are high, simply because annuity rates are very low. https://www.theguardian.com/money/2016/sep/14/annuity-rates-plummet-2016-worst-year-income-retiring-pensioners this site shows what has happened since Brexit and we expect rates to get better in the short term and I believe that any valuations now, will be significantly lower in 12 months’ time – The UK has already announced that interest rates will be rising to 0.5% next year, this will lower transfer values significantly.
  2. Going into the future, final salary schemes have cut income for members and many schemes have simply cut payments by 30% (via legal actuarial reductions). To back this up, please see this worrying article https://www.theguardian.com/money/2017/jan/04/final-salary-pension-deficit-biggest-listed-firms-uk with the total combined deficit in the UK for final salary pensions growing from £39 billion (2015) to £182 billion (to date).
  3. http://www.pionline.com/article/20170502/ONLINE/170509973/uk-corporate-pension-deficit-rises-nearly-6-in-april
  4. http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/pensions/article-3686601/Total-deficit-final-salary-schemes-soars-90bn-384bn-Brexit-hits-funds.html

If you would like a valuation on your pension please contact us directly or email to stuart@farringdongroup.com and we will uncomplicated this information and inform you of the options.

Thanks and have a great day

If you feel that this is of interest to colleagues, friends or family, please feel free to forward this information on.

I hope you enjoyed reading this post.

Stuart Yeomans 


Farringdon Group

Kuala Lumpur : Malaysia

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s